design netherlands School, May 1, 2008 8:19 AM 5 comments
Design Academy Unit Phase 2
Second half of an Atelier Module 3 class assignment for the second midterm presentation on April 23, 2008. Includes images of student work and comments from the instructors.

Continuing where Phase 1 of the assignment left off, the 30 or so students in this third year studio / creative processes class were asked to design, build and present 13 sub-projects to complete our original unit's 'world'. These included a:
- Wallpaper
- Toy and packaging
- Painting
- Process book
- Scale production model and mold
- Character profiles (alter ego, opposite guest, child, designer)
- Monogram stamp
- Textile with blockprint
- Drawings
- Unit
- Wall
- Personal 10 commandments

Three of our four instructors face the class to announce the scores.
We were asked to professionally present our collections in the studio space for private review by our four instructors and the Atelier department head. By the end of the day they sat all the students down and announced each person's score (out of 10) and brief comments. Below, a sampling of the student work.










































Clean-up before the scores.

Waiting for the reviews.

Post-critique beer.
It was also announced that five students would be asked to not continue in the class nor participate in the final assignment. Some of the English comments directed at students:
"It's a struggle for us watching you. There isn't a future for you here."
"We question if you can handle it."
"You should criticize yourself a bit more."
And for myself, I received a 5/10 score, and was asked not to return to Atelier: "You're too strict. You don't go off the path. You don't play. You would do well in Forum. Or maybe even Lab. I looked at your notebook: you're a thinker. I'm sorry, but you can't be in Atelier."
If you are a student featured here and would like your name associated with your work (for like, the Googlin' hits), drop me a message jeff [atsy] jeffwerner [dotsy] ca. And apologies to anyone I missed.
5 comments on Design Academy Unit Phase 2
1. Tyler | May 1, 2008 10:10 AM
Your instructors are jerk-heads with pompous hair. You can delete this if you think they might see it.
2. Dylan | May 1, 2008 10:12 AM
Smoking inside buildings!
And bummer they asked you not to come back pal.
3. Andreas | May 2, 2008 3:23 AM
Looks like you have a lot of space in there. Awesome critique. Way to go academy and design masochism.
4. Graham | May 4, 2008 10:20 PM
Harsh. I felt a bit sick just reading about it. Something I've found, personally, is that the more of an expert you become at something the tougher (and often more fickle) the criticism becomes.
In any case, Bali sounded much cooler than Atelier. I don't think you need these guys.
5. Paula Colchero | April 1, 2009 3:28 PM
What was that all about ha Jeff? ... I guess the beer was the best part ... we are soooooo much better off without these guys...!!
Article Sequence
- Home
- ↑ Next (May. 5-08): Emily Carr Design Graduation 2008
- ↓ Previous (Apr. 28-08): Utrecht Excursion
Categories
- About
- Currently
- Daily Activities
- Film
- Food
- Gallery
- Goods and Services
- In the News
- Links
- Music
- Portfolio
- Quotes
- Reading
- School
- Sports
- Travel
- Work
Feed, XHTML, CSS Movable Type 4.32-en
Recent Articles
- Mistakes I Made Last Week
- Rights I Made Last Week
- Mistakes I Made Last Week
- Emily Carr University 2010 Exhibition: Design
- Seymour + Cypress
- Womens Cycling Camp
- Mistakes I Made Last Week
- Pearl Izumi P.R.O. 2009 Cycling Shoes
- Cycling Vancouver to Blaine, USA
- Oregon to San Francisco
- Victoria to Oregon
- Vancouver to Victoria
- Art around town
- Subtle forks
- Buffalo Charging
Better than a thousand days of diligent study is one day with a great teacher.—Japanese proverb Copyright © 2002–2010 Jeff Werner, Creative Commons (Some rights reserved), Login
Leave a comment